Quick answer: No app is HIPAA compliant by itself, because compliance covers how you handle the whole workflow. With cloud transcription you need a signed business associate agreement (BAA) with the vendor. With on-device transcription, like Lyonesse, the audio is processed on your own device, so no transcription vendor receives it, unless you allow Apple's servers for a language with no on-device model.
Why Cloud Transcription Creates HIPAA Exposure
Under HIPAA, audio of a patient encounter is protected health information (PHI). When you upload it to a cloud transcription service, a third party receives PHI. That generally means:
- You need a signed business associate agreement (BAA) with that vendor.
- The recording is stored on the vendor's servers, under their access controls and retention.
- You inherit the vendor's breach risk. If they're compromised, so is your patients' data.
Many popular tools (Otter.ai, Rev, Fireflies.ai) are cloud-based, so using them for PHI puts all of that on your plate.
Compare a Cloud Service and an On-Device App
| Question | Cloud transcription service | On-device app (Lyonesse) |
|---|---|---|
| Who receives the audio | The vendor, on their servers | Nobody. It is processed on your device unless you opt into Apple-server transcription |
| BAA needed for the transcription step | Yes, with the vendor | No vendor receives the audio, unless you allow Apple's servers for a language with no on-device model. We don't sign BAAs |
| Where the copy lives | Vendor storage, plus whatever you download | Audio on your device. Notes sync through your iCloud if sync is on (it is by default) |
| What you still must do | Review the BAA, retention and subprocessors | Secure the device, manage backups, retention and consent |
HIPAA and Transcription Apps: What Lyonesse Does and Doesn't Do
Lyonesse transcribes recordings, dictation and imported files on your iPhone, iPad or Mac, with no account. You can generate summaries and ask questions about a recording locally. Audio stays on the device that recorded it. By default transcription runs on the device; Apple-server transcription is an opt-in you choose in the app.
Transcripts and summaries do sync between your own devices through iCloud, and iCloud sync is on by default. You can switch it off in Settings. See our privacy policy for the details. For therapy and counselling notes, see session notes for therapists and lawyers.
What You Still Have to Handle
- Device security. A strong passcode and biometric lock.
- Backups. iCloud and computer backups of the device can include your Lyonesse data. Check your backup settings.
- Retention and deletion. Delete recordings and transcripts once they're in your records system or no longer needed.
- Patient consent. Tell people they're being recorded and follow your local recording laws.
- Your own policies. Export to approved systems only, and run the workflow past your compliance officer.
Lyonesse is not a clinical documentation product and does not replace advice from a compliance officer or lawyer.
HIPAA and Recording: Consent and Where Audio Is Stored
Recording a patient raises two separate questions. First, consent: recording laws vary by state, and your own policies may be stricter. Second, storage: where does the audio end up? A cloud recorder puts a copy on the vendor's servers. In Lyonesse the audio stays on the device that recorded it and doesn't sync to iCloud, though a device backup can still contain it.
HIPAA and Transcription Services: What to Ask a Vendor
If you do use a cloud service, ask these before you upload anything:
- Will you sign a BAA, and does it cover the exact plan I'd be on?
- How long do you keep audio and transcripts, and can I delete them?
- Which subprocessors or AI providers see my audio?
- Do you train models on my data?
- Who at your company can access recordings?
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a HIPAA compliant transcription app?
Compliance depends on your overall workflow, not the app alone. Cloud tools need a BAA with the vendor. On-device transcription, like Lyonesse, means no transcription vendor receives the audio, unless you allow Apple's servers for a language with no on-device model. It is not a compliance guarantee, and your device, backup and retention choices still count.
Why is cloud transcription a HIPAA risk?
It uploads patient audio to a third party's servers, which generally requires a BAA and puts PHI under the vendor's storage, staff access and breach risk.
How do I transcribe patient recordings privately?
Use an on-device app so audio is processed locally. Lyonesse transcribes recordings and imported files on iPhone, iPad and Mac with no account. You still need to secure the device, manage backups and retention, and follow your own policies.
Does Lyonesse sign a BAA?
No. Audio stays on your device. Transcripts stay on your devices and in your own iCloud if you leave sync on. We run no servers that receive them, so there is nothing for us to process on your behalf. Whether that is enough for your situation is a question for your compliance officer.
Can I use Voice Memos or Apple's transcription for patient audio?
We can't answer that for you. Whether Apple's tools keep audio on the device can depend on the feature and your settings, so read Apple's privacy documentation for the exact feature, and ask your compliance officer before using it for patient audio.
Related reading: guide to private transcription apps, on-device AI compared with cloud AI, and Apple's privacy documentation.